January 05, 2009
Well Lookit That

As with most apocalyptic predictions, the chicken-little forecast of arctic ice disappearing completely in 2008 ended up flat wrong. The stuff actually increased during the year, for reasons scientists only puzzled out after the fact.

Now, tell me again, and slowly because I guess I'm just that retarded, why I should support inhibiting the economic growth of my country on the predictions of, presumably, these exact same scientists?

Those who think global warming is a) mostly man-made and b) a dire and immediate threat to civilization would do well to remember an axiom about science: "we love science because it can find The Ultimate Answer to any particular question. We hate science because it will change The Ultimate Answer whenever conflicting data is found."

That sound you hear is the True Believers moving the goalposts. Again.

Via No Pasaran.

Posted by scott at January 05, 2009 02:37 PM

eMail this entry!
Comments

When stuff like this gets introduced to an argument, I tend to get two responses:

1 - the zealot - the study is flawed due to XYZ, America is killing the planet
2 - the science-type - one year does not a trend make

Discussions with #2 are always more informative than those with #1.

But then again, #2 is more fun than #1. Just more satisfying in general.

Posted by: ronaprhys on January 5, 2009 03:38 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?