November 08, 2002
Looks Like They're Making Their Own Boycott

Sometimes I feel a little envious when I read about the latest stuff Jim, Aaron, or Jason is listening to, because I haven't purchased a new CD in probably five or six years now. Then I read things like this, and then I start to think they'll be joining me soon enough.

Want you all to listen up: if AOL can give away millions of CDs, that means they can be manufactured essentially for free. We're already being charged a "tax" on both blank tapes and CDs which goes straight to the record companies. The record companies cleared billions of dollars in net profit last year. Now they're breaking compatibility with existing players, meaning "upgrade or else".

Enough already. Vote with your pocketbooks and stop buying music. BOYCOTT is an ugly word to any industry, because it works.

Posted by scott at November 08, 2002 02:47 PM

eMail this entry!

Alright who is going to paint the signs and where are we going to march!

Posted by: Pat on November 8, 2002 06:48 PM

You forget that I stacked most of your CDs in that new place of yours. I know that you've gotten a few newer CDs, Mister Star Wars Episode I CD.
Gives new meaning to the "starving musician" saying.

Posted by: Cindy on November 8, 2002 11:31 PM

I got an episode I CD?!? Where?!?

I think the last thing I personally bought was a goofy telarc star trek compilation. Ellen's bought some stuff after that though. She's part of the problem!

Posted by: scott on November 9, 2002 10:29 AM

I can appreciate the emotion which springs forth when dealing with the music industry. It's so much fun to get all charged up over imagined injustices; to make signs and march in endless circles; looking busy but never quite going anywhere or accomplishing anything.

It is, however, incumbent upon all of us to at least have a fleeting relationship with the truth.

It took me all of twenty minutes to go to the various websites and dig up this information...any of you could do the same...if you wanted to.

Here are the numbers for three of the largest music groups in the world:

Warner Music Group: Sales: $4.0 billion
(2001) Profit: $226 million 5.7%

Sony Music Group: Sales: $5.0 billion
(2001) Profit: $152 million 3.0%

BMG (Bertelsmann): Sales: $3.0 billion
(2000) Loss: $43 million -1.4%

BMG reports in euros which are roughly equivalent to dollars.

I dont know where you get your "fact" that record companies make "billions" in profits every year. It is clear they do billions in sales each year however, as everyone knows, sales are NOT the same as profits...not in the least.

As you can see, the profit margins here are nowhere near fact BMG is losing money.

Sure you can say they are all just a bunch of incompetent suits who dont know how to properly manage a business and you very well could be right. The fact is, however, you dont have any basis for your statements except for your perception of the music industry which are fueled by a whole bunch of half truths and assumptions.

I am not an apologist for anyone...I just hate it when people buy into these popular "positions" for no other reason than they happen to be "popular".

Posted by: mr. helpful on November 9, 2002 08:27 PM

Good enough. I did in fact try to research the profit reports, because, in spite of perception, I tend not to hang my fanny out with pure from-authority arguments. As I recall, the numbers I pulled were from a WIRED article, which just shows I should know better. Thanks for the correction.

Posted by: scott on November 9, 2002 09:04 PM

no problemo! thats why they call me "mr. helpful"

heh heh heh

Posted by: mrhelpful on November 9, 2002 11:31 PM

I thought you also had a Dixie Chicks CD in there (and they are fairly recent). You gonna blame that on Ellen too?

Posted by: Cindy on November 9, 2002 11:51 PM

Speaking of supposed Facts, according to EMI: "There are 250 Million blank CDRs and tapes bought and used this year for copying music in comparison to 213 Million prerecorded audio media"

Hmm, I suppose they are counting that 100 pack that I bought for backing up my computers and making some compilation CD's for my own use (still legal as far as I know). Since 98 of the CDRs have not been used (how many unused CDRs do you have?) - I think their numbers may be off a bit.

Posted by: bogie on November 11, 2002 06:42 AM

I agree that it does not hurt big bands to download a song or two. That's like taking some grass from a mansion, it matters not. But when you download songs from unknown bands, they need every penny they can get. It works both ways. Bands are not the music industry.

Posted by: Starving artist on April 10, 2004 09:18 PM
Post a comment

Email Address:



Remember info?