August 01, 2002
Snake Oil

I'm always surprised at how otherwise intelligent people still end up believing in the oddest stuff. John Edward (talks to dead people) and Sonya Fitzpatrick (the pet psychic) have hot TV shows; Ms. Cleo rolls a Jamaican laugh (with a California birth certificate) all the way to the bank at $4.99 a minute; Peter Popoff to this day thumps people on the head using Jeh-HAY-zuss to heal them of their troubles; and the suburban American landscape is dotted with palm readers and psychics who, for a fee, promise to help you with your troubles.

These people succeed because we want to believe in them. Most folks who read this site probably don't realize just how cold and frightening science can seem. We all have unexamined beliefs we've held on to since childhood. If you're not used to your beliefs being challenged, the ones that connect you to your past and the past of everyone who came before you, life seems to die a little each time someone shines a light on a belief and tells you it's wrong. Especially when things get desperate, when a parent, spouse, or child just isn't getting any better, the pull of the quick fix is powerful indeed.

We also have the more recent phenomena of angry people who think the world owes them whatever they want whenever they want. The words "personal responsibility" generate at best blank looks and demands for more. "Gangstas" to blacks and "trailer trash" to whites, they all seem to end up doing the same talk show circuit together (there must be a club somewhere) screaming the same obscenities together, forming the background noise of a modern society that allows a human being to reach adulthood without actually requiring them to grow up.

Sometimes it's laughably easy to detect the scam. Sometimes it's not. Always remember just because you can't explain it scientifically doesn't mean there's not a scientific explanation for it. Human beings are fiendishly clever critters when it comes to fleecing each other, and their inventiveness can astound. And it always plays on your assumptions. A psychic who allows you to tie his hands to a chair will amaze you when the spirits he summons in the dark move things around. You'd probably never noticed the hinged chair arms that come loose in the dark. A faith healer who walks up and tells you your name, your age, and what is wrong with you is unbearably exciting. You'd probably never think to look inside his ear for the radio that connects him to an assistant reading from cards in a back room.

Personally I have no idea how John Edward does what he does. He's darned good at it, whatever it is. Always charming, usually funny, at times even profound, people are left gasping at what he tells them, visibly moved. Personal "readings" bring individuals to tears and laughter and almost physical relief. People walk into his shows vibrating like coiled springs full of grief and despair and leave gratefully with peace and happiness.

Which brings up an important point. We all know about the placebo affect. When drinking "vite-a-tonic" relieves some people's symptoms, does that make it wrong? If visiting a tent revival coinicides with someone's own immune system sending a cancer into remission, was any harm done? If what a psychic makes up and puts in your dead child's mouth helps you sleep at night, is it really a crime?

The problem is all of these people charge you money. Up front. Usually a lot of it. This has throughout history implied the promised trade of the truth of something real for the truth of real money. And yet the people supposedly just trying to help you already know all of these things, all of these things, are lies.

These people are leeches on a society, providing little if any good while sucking away sometimes the entire life savings of those they purport "help". The harm comes from all the people who drank the tonic instead of taking their medicine, or who saw the faith healer instead of the doctor, or who visited the psychic instead of the therapist. If all you're going to give me is gambler's odds, what the hell good are you?

Some of these people may be at heart kind, decent folk who think they're just helping ease people's minds. I have a feeling most of them are not. But if you really do think you're helping people, really making a difference by telling them what they want to hear, giving them what they already have, teaching them what they already know, and hell maybe you are, that's fine.

I'm sure if your customers agree they'll have no problem at all dropping a donation in your box as they leave.

Posted by scott at August 01, 2002 07:48 PM

eMail this entry!
Comments

The solution to the problem is easy: provide trustworthy and rational individuals as test subjects to debunk these folks. (Guerilla James Randi tactics?)

I had the mixed-fortune to get a free reading from Sonya Fitzpatrick from one of her many appearances on the thankfully-defunct Debra Duncan show here in Houston, Texas. I brought my cat Piper with me, and Sonya proceeded to call Piper a "He" and "Him" repeatedly, reading that he was nervous and frightened and worried.

Well, I'll give Sonya a point for seeing that Piper had shed all over my swearer and clung to me like a tree-monkey, but Piper's a very demure "She" thank you very much. Oddly enough, she identified every other animal by their proper gender.

How did Sonya blow a fifty-fifty basic fact about a cat? Well, Piper was the only animal she didn't "Pre-read" before the show. She talked with the owners at length, got their stories, and then repeated most of it on the air.

Posted by: Laurence Simon on August 5, 2002 12:57 PM

Cool! I was hoping someone who'd actually met one of these people would chime in. Thanks!

Posted by: Scott on August 5, 2002 06:06 PM

I saw a show that said some of these "mediums" actually get a guest list and do some investigative snooping...getting into someone's home either through a visiting "salesman" or some other way and noticing objects and photos...then talking about theses...this is all really well planned out. Looking into someone's past medical records...etc. Interviews of "nursing staff", stories in some way in records somewhere. It's really sick but, if you think about it, easy to do.

Posted by: Sheila Montgomery on July 30, 2003 02:44 PM

I need to talk to sonya: I'm a huge fan & i had a black & white siberian husky dog - sasha stolen from me while i was at work i think she was 3wks pregnate for her first litter. It happened on Oct24/00. I can't seem to let it go i need to find her or if she's still alive. I haven't had a good nights sleep since. even though we have another 1 kacie it's not the same not knowing. Please make sure sonya gets this nobody will help me and others have told me to let it go but being the animal lover i am i can't. thank you please help shirlee

Posted by: shirlee Michael on February 1, 2004 03:53 PM

I need to talk to sonya: I'm a huge fan & i had a black & white siberian husky dog - sasha stolen from me while i was at work i think she was 3wks pregnate for her first litter. It happened on Oct24/00. I can't seem to let it go i need to find her or if she's still alive. I haven't had a good nights sleep since. even though we have another 1 kacie it's not the same not knowing. Please make sure sonya gets this nobody will help me and others have told me to let it go but being the animal lover i am i can't. thank you please help shirlee

Posted by: shirlee Michael on February 1, 2004 03:53 PM

This is cool, you have to try it. I guessed 70815, and this game guessed it! See it here - http://www.funbrain.com/guess/

Posted by: Allison Trump on May 9, 2006 03:33 AM

Thank you for the postings. I was about to send Sonya $300 that I don't have because I am so distraught over putting my beloved Trudy down. Something made me wonder why she didn't have her show anymore (it was so highly rated), so I googled her name and found your website, as well as others that have convinced me she is a sham. I still believe that some people have a gift, but those are the ones who successfully help police solve crimes and shun the publicity. I am going to have to learn to live with the pain and uncertainty that I did the right thing for Trudy for the rest of my life.

Posted by: Carol on June 3, 2006 09:53 PM

Thank you for the postings. I was about to send Sonya $300 that I don't have because I am so distraught over putting my beloved Trudy down. Something made me wonder why she didn't have her show anymore (it was so highly rated), so I googled her name and found your website, as well as others that have convinced me she is a sham. I still believe that some people have a gift, but those are the ones who successfully help police solve crimes and shun the publicity. I am going to have to learn to live with the pain and uncertainty that I did the right thing for Trudy for the rest of my life.

Posted by: Carol on June 3, 2006 09:53 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?